First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

IRS finds churches, charities overstep into politics

By The Associated Press
03.02.06

WASHINGTON — IRS exams found nearly three out of four churches, charities and other civic groups suspected of having violated restraints on political activity in the 2004 election actually did so, the agency said.

Most of the examinations that have concluded found only a single, isolated incidence of prohibited campaign activity.

In three cases, however, the IRS uncovered violations egregious enough to recommend revoking the groups' tax-exempt status.

The vast majority of charities and churches followed the law, but the examinations found a "disturbing" amount of political intervention in the 2004 elections, IRS Commissioner Mark Everson said.

"It's disturbing not because it's pervasive, but because it has the potential to really grow and have a very bad impact on the integrity of charities and churches," Everson said in a Feb. 24 interview.

The tax agency looked only at charities, churches and other tax-exempt organizations referred to the IRS for potentially violating laws that bar them from participating in or intervening in elections, including advocating for or against any candidate.

Those referred to the IRS represent a tiny fraction of more than 1 million tax-exempt groups organized under section 501(c)(3) of the tax law.

The IRS examined 110 organizations referred to the tax agency for potential violations, and 28 cases remain open.

Among the 82 closed cases, the IRS found prohibited politicking and sent a written warning to 55 organizations and assessed a penalty tax against one group. Those organizations included 37 churches and 19 other organizations.

In the three additional cases in which the IRS recommended revoking tax-exempt status, none of the organizations were churches. The agency did not identify the three.

The IRS found tax violations unrelated to politics in five cases. Examinations of the 18 remaining groups did not turn up any wrongdoing.

In some cases, the IRS found flagrant violations of the law. In others, charities did not understand their obligations. Many activities fall into an ambiguous area that requires closer scrutiny of context and timing.

"There are very few places where you can draw bright lines," Everson said. "People have to think about this."

Among the prohibited activities, the examiners found that charities and churches had distributed printed material supporting a preferred candidate and assembled improper voter guides or candidate ratings. Religious leaders had used the pulpit to endorse or oppose a particular candidate, and some groups had shown preferential treatment to candidates by letting them speak at functions.

Other charities and churches had made improper cash contributions to a candidate's political campaign.

The IRS said the cases covered "the full spectrum" of political viewpoints.

The tax agency set up a task force in 2004 to review allegations of improper political activity. The special procedures, revealed shortly before the election, drew criticism from some tax-exempt groups.

An audit by Treasury Department inspectors found nothing inappropriate in the examinations, but it faulted the IRS for creating the appearance of political motivations by waiting too long to announce the project and contact organizations.

The IRS said it planned to continue using the task force, and its speedier procedures, for this year's election and in the future. It also released detailed guidance to charities and churches about the prohibitions against political activities.


Related

N.C. church split highlights divide over pulpit politics

Some Christians say minister went too far in telling parishioners to vote for Bush, but younger churchgoers favor political expression in sermons; at stake: tax exemptions, church-state entanglement. 05.19.05

L.A. church's tax status in jeopardy over anti-war sermon, priest says

All Souls Episcopal officials say IRS has warned liberal church that it may lose tax exemption for homily delivered on eve of 2004 presidential election. 11.08.05

2 evangelical churches accused of illegal politicking
Thirty-one religious leaders ask IRS to determine whether Ohio churches should lose tax-exempt status because of their support for gubernatorial candidate. 01.19.06

Minister who endorsed Huckabee prays for death of critics
Pastor of Buena Park, Calif., Baptist church calls for 'imprecatory prayer' targeting Americans United officials for filing IRS complaint against him. 08.17.07

Minn. minister tests prohibition on political preaching
Church-state separation group asked for IRS probe after Rev. Gus Booth alerted group to sermon he gave last month urging followers to oppose Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton. 06.14.08

The case against All Saints: Has the IRS gone too far?
By Charles C. Haynes Anti-war sermon on eve of '04 election draws threat to liberal church's tax exemption — a threat many evangelicals say they've been under for years. 11.27.05

IRS to churches: Watch what you preach
By Charles C. Haynes Conflicts over churches' political role have heated up again for this election cycle. 10.01.06

Tax exemptions

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Wednesday, June 19, 2013 | 04:33:52
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
1 for All
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings®
Events
Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links